Feeling like a fraud is normal for high achievers

Imposter syndrome, first described as the "impostor phenomenon" by psychologists Pauline Clance and Suzanne Imes in 1978, is the persistent feeling that you're a fraud despite real evidence of success. It's especially common among high achievers. A 2020 review of 62 studies found rates ranging from 9% to 82%, depending on the group studied.

Here's a thought that shows up in almost every client I talk to: Any day now, they're going to figure out I don't know what I'm doing.

It shows up in business owners with ten years of experience and a waitlist. It shows up after a big win, which is the strangest part. You land the biggest client of your career, and instead of feeling proud, you feel like you tricked them.

If this sounds like you, I want you to know two things. It has a name. And it tends to show up in people who are good at what they do.

Where the term came from

In 1978, two psychologists named Pauline Clance and Suzanne Imes published a paper describing something they kept seeing in their therapy practice: accomplished women who had earned degrees, promotions, and honors, yet were convinced they weren't really smart or capable. These women believed they had fooled everyone, and lived in fear of being found out.

Clance and Imes called it the impostor phenomenon. (The popular term "imposter syndrome" came later, and it's not an official diagnosis.)

Notice who they were describing: high achievers. People with real evidence of their competence, who somehow couldn't absorb it.

It's incredibly common

In 2020, a team led by Dena Bravata published a systematic review of the research on impostor feelings. They looked across 62 studies. The reported rates varied hugely, from 9% of people in some studies to 82% in others, depending on who was studied and how it was measured.

That range tells you two things. Researchers still disagree on how to measure it. And in some groups, it's more common to feel like an impostor than not. Later research also found that it isn't just a women's issue. Men experience it too, though they may talk about it less.

So if you've felt this, you're in very good company.

How impostor feelings work

The core pattern is how you explain your own results.

When something goes well, you give the credit to something outside you. I got lucky. The client was easy. The timing was right. Anyone could have done it.

When something goes badly, you give the blame to something inside you. See? I'm not actually good at this.

Run that pattern long enough, and no amount of success can convince you. Every win gets explained away. Every setback gets filed as proof.

Why it matters for your business

Impostor feelings aren't just uncomfortable. They quietly cost you money and time:

  • You undercharge, because charging what you're worth feels like a claim you can't back up.

  • You over-prepare, spending hours on things that needed minutes, just to feel safe.

  • You avoid visibility, because being seen means being "found out."

  • You hesitate to say yes to opportunities you're completely qualified for.

What actually helps

You can't argue yourself out of impostor feelings with pep talks. But you can change what you pay attention to.

1. Keep an evidence file. A folder, a doc, a note on your phone. Every time a client thanks you, gets a result, or refers someone, save it. Impostor feelings run on selective memory. Evidence interrupts it.

2. Catch the explanation. When something goes well, notice if you're about to say "I just got lucky." Ask: What did I actually do that contributed to this? There's always something.

3. Say it out loud to someone. Impostor feelings love secrecy. When you tell someone you trust, you'll very often hear "Oh my gosh, me too." The shame shrinks fast.

4. Separate feelings from facts. "I feel like a fraud" is a feeling. "I've served 40 clients who got results" is a fact. You don't have to wait for the feeling to go away to act on the facts.

5. Let it come along for the ride. Many successful people never fully lose the feeling. They just stop letting it make decisions. You can feel like an impostor and send the proposal anyway.

You're not a fraud. You're growing.

Here's a reframe I love. Impostor feelings often show up when you're stepping into something new, at the edge of your comfort zone. They can be a sign that you're growing, not a sign that you're failing. The people who never feel this way are often the ones who've stopped stretching.

So the next time that voice says they're going to find out, answer it: Yes. They're going to find out I'm good at this.

If impostor feelings are keeping you from raising your rates or going after bigger clients, let's work through it together.

Clance & Imes (1978), Psychotherapy: Theory, Research & Practice · Bravata et al. (2020), "Prevalence, Predictors, and Treatment of Impostor Syndrome," Journal of General Internal Medicine

Frequently asked questions

What is imposter syndrome?

Imposter syndrome is the feeling that you aren't as capable as others think and will eventually be found out, even when you have clear evidence of your competence. Clance and Imes originally called it the "impostor phenomenon." It isn't an official diagnosis.

Why do high achievers get imposter syndrome?

People with impostor feelings tend to credit their successes to luck or outside factors and blame their setbacks on themselves. That pattern lets them explain away every win, no matter how much they accomplish.

How do business owners overcome imposter syndrome?

Keep a file of client wins and thank-you notes, notice when you attribute success to luck, talk about it with someone you trust, and separate the feeling from the facts. You can feel like an impostor and still send the proposal.

Hannah Cox

Hannah Cox is an accountability coach and the founder of The Execution Expert. For more than six years, she has helped 700+ business owners, founders and executives follow through on what they already know they need to do.

https://www.coachhannahcox.com
Previous
Previous

Your expectations become their performance

Next
Next

Forgive yourself for procrastinating (it works)